NEVER do an after action report

 

NEVER do an after action report

 

How on Earth did we end up with negative rates? Simple, by avoiding as much as possible any “wargaming” of economic predicaments.

 Thanks to a friend, Marc Udeschini,  for starting my down this rabbit hole. He asked: "Is a period of hot inflation the likely path forward?".

That got me thinking, not so much about the future as about  the past.

 After all, one of the high point in my life was meeting a person who was a "high priest" in insurance since the 60ies. I won't name him because he passed away and he was quite prominent, but after the meeting we talked a little, liked each other's way of thinking, and started REALLY talking. at some point, I asked him "Why do life policies carry a 4% minimum guaranteed return?".

He told me that prior to the Yom Kippur oil crisis and the resulting inflation explosion, Insurance companies merely gathered assets by offering a fixed 4% return  against their name. Fast forward to 1974, and one year rates in Italy reach 18% (!). So, in order not to be wiped out by mobs of clients demanding their money back, they promise to give back 80% of the yield on their financial portfolio, with the OLD guaranteed rate becoming a never to be breached minimum guarantee. And when I asked to this old sage I was in awe of, "did you have any hint of what was about to happen, earlier in the 70ies?", his answer was "Not a clue".

So, as in my old age I decided that being prepared beats being a clairvoyant, let's roll onto the past.

 How the heck did we get here??

That's where Marc had me click. After all, there IS a country which is further along everyone else down the rabbit hole: Japan. And I seem to recollect that when the ECB was starting its "Drang nach Osten" towards negative rates, she anwered the meager band of skeptics with words like "We are not Japan".

Well, a decade on, here we are, and the first casualty of that drive was that phrase.

What did we miss? A thorough AND PUBLIC discussion about the Japanese financial history, or for the Militarily inclined, an AAR (After Action Report).

Just to make it clear, this is the Topix index including dividends, as per Bloomberg LP:


 Bear in mind that this total return index is still BELOW the 1989 peak. But over long periods, and before this abnormal interest rates environment, "time value of money" still meant something. You invested in Japanese shares only if you thought you could beat the Japanese Government Bond rate of over 5%, or not at all. 

Now, think what would have happened to a shy but young "Sarariman" who wanted to have some retirement money stashed away, who perchance knew someone at the Finance Ministry who could arrange this mutually beneficial deal: the young pup would pay 50 million Yen now, in order to buy a 30 year zero coupon at slightly lower rates than those prevailing on 10 year bonds, seen below.

 

 

They agree on 5% instead of the 5,6% of the ten year, delivery against payment.

So, since over 30 years have elapsed, where is our VERY shy employee now?

 Be advised if you are younger than my 58 years, that at the time Japan inc. was on a roll and represented 40% of the world equity markets. Books were published saying things like "Japan will conquer the world" or "The Imperial palace in Japan is worth like the whole of California", so practically EVERY international long investor had a sizable chunk there... and now?


Yyyep, that guy was lucky. Here are the numbers, for those who want a quick recap:


start date 31/12/1989
end date 18/11/2020
Years elapsed 30,9
Rate 5%
capitalization factor 4,52
(1+ 5%) ^ 30,9
amount 50.000.000
Final amount 225.842.891


Topix at start 2.888

So, at what level of the Topix, including reinvested dividends, consummate pros who held fast will reach that (formerly) young buck? + 2.888 * 4,52 = 13.045 or thereabouts. So, if and when someone tells you "THE JAPANESE MARKET MAKES NEW HISTORIC HIGHS", hold the Champagne. Root beer is nearer the mark.

So what's the gist of my writing? it's that BEFORE embarking in policies remotely likely to land us there, Western Central Banks should have started a frank discussion of the pros and cons, and make no bones that for once, they did not crave "compliance": they wanted the best professionals to ruthlessly shoot at that plan to see if it still floated afterwards.

That unfortunately did not happen. So, from then on, we've skipped from crisis to crisis like a stone across a pond.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The NATO the I used to know

Image
  The NATO that I used to know There is now an avowed crisis in NATO, an organization that has been unable to inspire confidence in the citizens it is supposed to protect. Pity it does such a good job to protect its supposed reputation, but that's bureaucracy for you. This article has been inspired by a Wall Street Journal piece which is singularly below the usual high standard of journalistic integrity they apply, and that can be found here: https://www.wsj.com/articles/nato-countries-defense-spending-europe-russia-ukraine-2cae6723?st=ei8f5zo4ptb4txq While the article quotes official sources the message is deceptive: on reading it one would think European members of NATO have largely mended their miserly ways and are now serious about being actually able to defend themselves, while reality projects a very different message. There are points that are particularly misleading so I will parse it. “ Some 23 of 32 NATO member countries are on track to spend at least 2% of t...
Read more

Milei: The only real news of the year

  Milei: The only real news of the year The year 2023 has been far from uneventful and there are scores of very good “year in review” posts. But for an Italian like me, and for the world in general, nothing in my opinion comes close to the free election of Milei in Argentina. Argentina has been a sick man of South America for longer than I have been alive. But that was not always the case, and while present day society, with its weak familial relationships and indifference of history can ignore it, It was indeed a wealthy and thriving society in the latter part of the 1800 and early 1900. For me, that's part of the family lore since of the five brothers one of which was my paternal grandfather, three emigrated to Argentina in the early part of the past century. I probably have more relations there than here in Italy. That was partly due to a federalist constitution and a series of market friendly governments which allowed the country to make the most of its advantages...
Read more

THE END OF MELONI?

August 9th, 2023   THE END OF MELONI? DISCLAIMER: nothing in this article is or is meant to be "financial advice" under current legislation. drink fluids, eat healthy and exercise. I had some doubts about how the new government of Italy would develop, see my previous post on the subject . But here we are, not one year into the current government, and it all falls apart in one day. First an explanation: by “fall apart” I do not mean that the government falls, loses parliamentary votes, suffers internal defections etc. If anything, the one speculative thoughts I had, that Meloni would last the legislature, is the less dented of my opinions, expectations and desires. In fact, I surmise that between declaring the experience ended and proclaiming a snap election, or the present predicament, the first was the better alternative... provided she had an inkling about what happened. What I mean is that what made Meloni "something else" is lost, and probably irretrie...
Read more